Publication Type

Working Paper

Version

publishedVersion

Publication Date

10-2026

Abstract

Problem definition: A significant portion of the food loss in agricultural supply chains occurs at the farm level and has been linked to high cosmetic standards adopted by retailers regarding the size, color, and shape of the produce. We examine the economic incentives for retailers to adopt such high standards and their impact on food loss. Methodology/results: We build a sequential game between a retailer and a farmer, where the retailer signs a contract with the farmer, specifying a cosmetic standard as well as the wholesale price and contract volume. Setting a high standard allows the retailer to sell the produce at a price premium but increases the rejection rate, i.e., reduces the proportion of produce satisfying this standard. We find that compared to a low cosmetic standard, a high standard does not always increase food loss and could actually lower food loss because the retailer may set a higher contract volume that increases the quantity that can be sold to the retailer, or a higher wholesale price that incentivizes the farmer to exert more effort. We also find that food loss may change in a non-monotonic fashion in the difference of the rejection rate between both standards, the farmer’s effort cost, and the reduction in the price premium. Managerial implications: These results imply that banning cosmetic standards may backfire and increase food loss instead. When retailers set a high cosmetic standard, we show that agricultural research and development to reduce either the rejection rate under the high standard or the effort cost is an effective policy intervention. Consumer education campaigns to shape perceptions of cosmetic standards may be ineffective, particularly if they lower the willingness-to-pay for a high standard rather than increase it for the low standard. We confirm the robustness of our results and policy implications in the presence of an alternative sales channel, for a vertically integrated retailer, and with more granular cosmetic standards.

Keywords

Food loss, Cosmetic standard, Agricultural contract, Government policy

Discipline

Agricultural and Resource Economics | Food Studies | Operations and Supply Chain Management

Research Areas

Operations Management

First Page

1

Last Page

49

Copyright Owner and License

Authors

Share

COinS